Opponents of Official English policies argue that this type of legislation is unconstitutional. Early on in American history, English co-existed with German, and then eventually with French and Spanish. This was about two months before Thomas Jefferson used it when penning the Declaration of Independence.
As may be expected, many Democrats including the Clinton administration have tended to lobby against Official English policies along with other organizations such as the ACLU, various pro-bilingual associations, minority based non-profits groups as well as the National Education Association.
French, German, Italian and Romansh. English is the de facto language since, at this point, it is the most widely spoken language in the nation. Circuit Court of Appeals found the Arizona law to violate free speech and ruled that a person's choice of language is a right to speech, " 'Speech in any language is still speech, and the decision to speak in another language is a decision involving speech alone,' Judge Stephen Reinhardt wrote for the majority" First Amendment News But, language is different, as an individual can choose to learn English.
Accordingly, these individuals can become more productive members of society and escape any dependence they may have on others. Real forms of discrimination aim at the inherent characteristics of an individual that they cannot change such as their skin color or national origin.
Employers want to train employees in their native languages.
The most emotional argument that proponents of Official English legislation will debate, is the idea of unity. Another popular name for the U.
Individuals who oppose establishing an official language have alternative feelings of unequal treatment, discriminatory action, view multilingual as an asset, and believe such legislation is unnecessary.
This appears to be the most serious of bills as it seeks to amend on of the founding documents of this nation.
Of all the foreign languages spoken in the country, Spanish is the language spoken most frequentlyaccording to the Census Bureau. Various media sources, research firms, and government agencies have attempted to specifically assess the sentiment of the general public concerning multilingualism and English Only policies.
Many feel that by accommodating non-English speakers, one is performing a disservice to them by discouraging assimilation. This would unreasonably burden government services, adding a huge layer of bureaucracy and costs. Proponents of Official English laws feel that translating government documents, even into just a handful of additional languages is inefficient and an unnecessary cost.
US Census Bureau English should be declared the official language of the United States.
The United States is made up of many diverse peoples with origins from all over the world. Despite this, they have traditionally been able to come together and become American. One of the most important things that made this possible was the adoption of the English language.
Declaring English as the official language of the United States is an idea that quite dangerous and culturally insensitive and many issues exist with the creation of an official language that one might not always foresee when making such an argument.
Review opinions on the online debate English should be the official language of the United States. DEBATES. English should be the official language of the United States but it is not the only language spoken in the United States.
Making English the national language and relieving the government from its responsibility of providing. Though the United States has no official language at the federal level, bills are continually introduced in both houses of Congress calling for the establishment of English as the nation’s sole official language.
A new national survey has reaffirmed clear and strong public support for English as the official and unifying language of the United States, with 73% of likely voters agreeing that Official English legislation should be.
Official English laws make it necessary for governments to provide information and services in English only, and does not protect the "right" of non-English speakers to receive govt information and services in another language.Download